AMSOIL Gear Lube Study Comparison Tests
 

Read our new White Paper

A Study of Automotive Gear Lubes
The most comprehensive Automotive Gear Lube testing
Click Here to Downlaod (2MB PDF)


Overview

The requirements for automotive gear lubrication have changed over the years, yet vehicle owner awareness has not. Gear lubrication has been commonly considered elementary, but, in fact, it is a dynamic process that requires sophisticated technology. The differentials that house the gears are out of sight, out of mind. They are neglected. But differentials are just as important to the operation of a vehicle as the engine. An engine without a functioning differential will not move the vehicle. Gear lubrication needs to be taken more seriously than before. There are several forces driving the need for better gear lubrication.

First, is improved fuel economy. Modern vehicle aerodynamics, with lower level air dams, is decreasing the air flow over differentials. Fuel economy is improved, but reduced air flow increases differential operating temperatures. Also, lubricant fill volumes in differentials have been reduced in order to lower fluid drag on the gears and bearings for further improvement in fuel economy. However, lubricants cool components, and with less fluid in the sump, operating temperatures rise. Improvements in vehicle performance have created additional need for more sophisticated gear lubrication. Model-year 2007 turbo diesel pickup trucks, V-10 gasoline pickups and sport utility vehicles (SUVs), and high-horsepower V-8 trucks have more towing and payload capacities than in previous years, yet their differentials have not changed. There has been a 34% increase in engine horsepower over the last decade, while axle gear sizes have remained constant, sump capacities have been lowered and drain intervals extended. In the light truck segment there has been a 93% horsepower increase since 1981.1 In vehicles such as a fifth-wheel equipped Ford F-350 Super Duty, towing capacities have reached a high of 19,200 lbs.2 And testing shows that in new axle applications simulating trailer towing at 88 km/h (55 mph) at a 3.5% grade temperatures can reach as high as 188°C (370°F).3 Stress on differentials has also increased in limousines, conversion vans, and trucks and cars with modified, high-performance engines. More power, more towing capacity and higher hauling limits greatly increase the stress that causes heat and wear.

Improvements in vehicle comfort have also driven the need for better gear lubrication. The demand for greater interior space has forced vehicle manufacturers to lower floor boards, which restricts air flow to the differential. Hot exhaust systems are forced closer to the axle housing, and differential operating temperatures are increased even further. Most vehicles operate under severe service as defined by vehicle manufacturers, but the majority of vehicle owners are unaware of this. Severe service applications include towing, hauling, plowing, off-road use, frequent stop-and-go driving, steep-hill driving and temperature extremes. Severe service applications are on the rise. For example, more than 90 percent of Ford Super Duty pickups are used for towing.4 Severe service increases the need for better gear lubrication. Synthetic gear lubes are recognized as superior to petroleum-based gear lubes by vehicle manufacturers, gear manufacturers and most high-performance automotive experts. Synthetic gear lubes exhibit all-around better performance. There are many synthetic gear lubricants available to consumers, including those marketed by vehicle manufacturers. All position themselves as superior to the rest.


Operating Conditions and Lubrication Requirements

Differentials contain many different components, each having its own requirements for lubrication. The ring and pinion gears operate under extreme pressure and sliding contact that require extreme-pressure additives for protection. The bearings operate under rolling motion where lubricant film strength is particularly important, and limited-slip clutches require special friction additives for proper operation. It is essential, therefore, that gear lube formulations be carefully balanced to protect all components. Too much emphasis on the needs of one component can detract from the needs of another.

Differential

Purpose

The purpose of this paper is to inform consumers about the increasingly severe conditions under which differentials operate and to provide data reflecting the quality and cost differences of popular synthetic and petroleum gear lubes. With this information, consumers are better prepared to make informed decisions when purchasing gear lubricants.


Method

The testing by which the gear lubes were evaluated was done in accordance with American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) procedures, Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) J306 requirements and Federal Test Method Standards. Other than the oxidation filter patch procedure, performance testing was conducted by an independent laboratory. Physical-property testing (viscosity, viscosity index, pour point and foaming after oxidation) was conducted in-house. A notarized affidavit certifying that the results are accurately reported is included in Appendix 1. Gear lube pricing was obtained from the manufacturers or distributors, and a notarized affidavit certifying that those prices are reported as obtained is included in Appendix 2.


Scope

The focus of this paper is on American Petroleum Institute (API) GL-5, SAE 75W-90 synthetic gear lubes. Samples of API GL-5, SAE 80W-90 petroleum gear lubes were also included for comparative purposes. The tests were selected to measure the properties consistent with extreme-pressure gear lubricant requirements and are intended to reveal the lubricants’ overall performance. The performance characteristics evaluated include each gear lube’s ability to:

1. Meet the required viscosity grade of an application
2. Maintain viscosity when subjected to temperature changes
3. Retain viscosity during use
4. Function in cold temperatures
5. Resist high temperatures and oxidation
6. Protect under extreme pressures
7. Protect against wear
8. Resist foaming
9. Prevent copper corrosion.

 




Click Here to Report Problems Or Comments
G-54
Wholesale AccountsOrdering InformationRequest Free CatalogOur TechnologyResearch ResourcesAMSOIL TestimonialsFind AMSOIL DealerFind AMSOIL RetailerContact UsDealer Services
3 Easy ways to place your order now!



About AMSOIL
AMSOIL HistoryCompany of Firsts40+ Years Track RecordProduct Introduction CronologyAMSOIL & EnvironmentISO 9001:2000 CertifiedProduct WarrantyAbout WBoil.com
Motor Oil
Gasoline Engine Oils
0W-16 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OES)0W-16 Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil (AZS)0W-16 100% Synthetic Hybrid Motor Oil (HE016)0W-20 Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil (ASM)0W-20 Extended Life Synthetic Motor Oil (XLZ)0W-20 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OEZ)0W-20 LS European Motor Oil (AFE)0W-20 LS-VW European Motor Oil (EZT)0W-20 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM020)0W-20 100% Synthetic Hybrid Motor Oil (HE020)0W-20 Synthetic-Blend Motor Oil (SB020)0W-30 MS European Motor Oil (EOT)0W-30 Signature Series (AZO)0W-40 Signature Series Motor Oil (AZF)0W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFO)0W-40 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OEG)5W-20 Extended Life Synthetic Motor Oil (XLM)5W-20 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OEM)5W-20 Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil (ALM)5W-20 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM520)5W-20 Synthetic-Blend Motor Oil (SB520)5W-30 Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil (ASL)5W-30 Extended Life Synthetic Motor Oil (XLF)5W-30 LS European Motor Oil (AEL)5W-30 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OEF)5W-30 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM530)5W-30 Synthetic-Blend Motor Oil (SB530)5W-40 MS European Motor Oil (AFL)5W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFM)5W-50 Signature Series Motor Oil (AMR)10W-30 Signature Series Synthetic Motor Oil (ATM)10W-30 Extended Life Synthetic Motor Oil (XLT)10W-30 OE Series Synthetic Motor Oil (OET)10W-30 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM1030)10W-40 Extended Life Synthetic Motor Oil (XLO)10W-40 Premium Protection Motor Oil (AMO)10W-60 FS European Motor Oil (ETS)20W-50 Premium Protection Motor Oil (ARO)
Diesel Engine Oils
0W-20 LS European Motor Oil (AFE)0W-20 LS-VW European Motor Oil (EZT)0W-20 Synthetic Diesel Oil (DP020)0W-30 MS European Motor Oil (EOT)0W40 Signature Series CK-4 Diesel Oil (DZF)0W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFO)5W-30 LS European Motor Oil (AEL)5W30 Signature Series CK-4 Diesel Oil (DHD)5W-30 Synthetic Diesel Oil (DP530)5W-40 MS European Motor Oil (AFL)5W40 Signature Series CK-4 Diesel Oil (DEO)5W40 Heavy-Duty CK-4 Diesel Oil (ADO)5W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFM)10W30 Heavy-Duty CK-4 Diesel Oil (ADN)10W30 Signature Series Diesel Oil (DTT)10W30 Commercial Grade Diesel Oil (SBDT)10W-40 Premium Protection Motor Oil (AMO)10W-60 FS European Motor Oil (ETS)15W-40 Heavy-Duty Diesel & Marine (AME)15W40 Heavy-Duty CK-4 Diesel Oil (ADP)15W40 Signature Series CK-4 Diesel Oil (DME)15W40 Commercial Grade Diesel Oil (SBDF)20W-50 Premium Protection Motor Oil (ARO)20W-50 DOMINATOR Competition Diesel Oil (DCO)
Motorcycle & Scooter Oils
V-Twin Oil Change Kit (HDCK)SAE 60 Motorcycle Oil (MCS)Engine Assembly Lube (EAL)V-Twin Synthetic Primary Fluid (MVP)V-Twin Synthetic Transmission Fluid (MVT)V-Twin Oil Change Kit (HDBK)V-Twin Oil Change Kit (HDMC)V-Twin Oil Change Kit (HDMB)5W-40 Synthetic Metric Motorcycle Oil (MMF)10W-30 Synthetic Metric Motorcycle Oil (MCT)10W-40 Synthetic Metric Motorcycle Oil (MCF)10W-40 Formula 4 Stroke® Synthetic Scooter Oil (ASO)10W-40 Dirt Bike Oil (DB40)10W-50 Dirt Bike Oil (DB50)10W-60 Dirt Bike Oil (DB60)15W-50 Synthetic Metric Motorcycle Oil (MFF)15W-60 Synthetic V-Twin Motorcycle Oil (MSV)20W-40 Synthetic V-Twin Motorcycle Oil (MVI)20W-50 Synthetic V-Twin Motorcycle Oil (MCV)
Marine Motor Oil
Outboard 100:1 Pre-Mix Synthetic 2-Stroke Oil (ATO)HP Marine Synthetic 2-Stroke Oil (HPM)10W-30 Formula 4-Stroke® Marine Synthetic Motor Oil (WCT)10W-40 Formula 4-Stroke® Marine Synthetic Motor Oil (WCF)15W-40 Heavy-Duty Diesel & Marine (AME)25W-40 Synthetic Blend Marine Engine Oil
Racing & High Performance
SAE 60 Dominator® Synthetic Racing Oil (RD60)Briggs & Stratton Synthetic 4T Racing Oil (GBS2960)Dominator® Synthetic 2-Cycle Racing Oil (TDR)SAE 30 Break-In Oil (BRK)Engine Assembly Lube (EAL)5W-20 Dominator® Synthetic Racing Oil (RD20)10W-30 Dominator® Synthetic Racing Oil (RD30)10W-40 Dominator® Synthetic Racing Oil (RD40)15W-50 Dominator® Synthetic Racing Oil (RD50)
Classic & High Performance
SAE 30 Break-In Oil (BRK)Engine Assembly Lube (EAL)10W-30 Z-ROD Synthetic Motor Oil (ZRT)10W-40 Premium Protection Motor Oil (AMO)10W-40 Z-ROD Synthetic Motor Oil (ZRD)20W-50 Premium Protection Motor Oil (ARO)20W-50 Z-ROD Synthetic Motor Oil (ZRF)
European Motor Oils
0W-20 LS European Motor Oil (AFE)0W-20 LS-VW European Motor Oil (EZT)0W-30 MS European Motor Oil (EOT)0W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFO)5W-30 LS European Motor Oil (AEL)5W-40 MS European Motor Oil (AFL)5W-40 FS European Motor Oil (EFM)10W-60 FS European Motor Oil (ETS)
High-Mileage Motor Oil
0W-20 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM020)5W-20 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM520)5W-30 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM530)10W-30 100% Synthetic High-Mileage Oil (HM1030)
Hybrid Motor Oil
0W-16 100% Synthetic Hybrid Motor Oil (HE016)0W-20 100% Synthetic Hybrid Motor Oil (HE020)
4-Stroke & Small Engine Oils
Briggs & Stratton Synthetic 4T Racing Oil (GBS2960)0W-40 Formula 4-Stroke® PowerSports Synthetic Motor Oil (AFF)5W-30 Synthetic Small Engine Oil (AES)10W-30 Formula 4-Stroke® Marine Synthetic Motor Oil (WCT)10W-30 Synthetic Small Engine Oil (ASE)10W-40 Formula 4 Stroke® Synthetic Scooter Oil (ASO)10W-40 Formula 4-Stroke® Marine Synthetic Motor Oil (WCF)10W-40 Synthetic Small Engine Oil (ASF)15W-50 Synthetic Small Engine Oil (SEF)25W-40 Synthetic Blend Marine Engine Oil
ATV & UTV Motor Oils
ATV/UTV Oil Change Kits (Polaris)ATV/UTV Oil Change Kits (Can-Am)0W-50 Synthetic ATV/UTV Motor Oil5W-40 Synthetic ATV/UTV Motor Oil5W-50 Synthetic ATV/UTV Motor Oil10W-30 Synthetic ATV/UTV Motor Oil10W-40 Synthetic ATV/UTV Motor Oil
2 Cycle / 2 Stroke Motor Oil
INTERCEPTOR™ 2-Cycle Oil (AIT) Synthetic 2-Stroke Injector Oil (AIO)Dominator® Synthetic 2-Cycle Racing Oil (TDR)Saber™ Synthetic 100:1 Pre-Mix 2-Cycle Oil (ATP)Outboard 100:1 Pre-Mix Synthetic 2-Stroke Oil (ATO)HP Marine Synthetic 2-Stroke Oil (HPM)
Natural Gas Engine Oil
15W-40 (SAE 40) Synthetic Vehicular Natural Gas Engine Oil (ANGV)20W-40 (SAE 40) Synthetic Stationary Natural Gas Engine Oil (ANGS)
Oil & Air Filtration
AMSOIL Motorcycle FiltersMotorcycle Oil Filter (Nano Fiber)AMSOIL Automotive Oil FiltersFull Flow Oil Filter (Nano Fiber)AMSOIL Ea Heavy Duty Oil FiltersHeavy Duty Extended-Life Oil FilterAMSOIL By-Pass Oil Filteration By-Pass Filteration Kits
BMK21 Universal Single-Remote Bypass SystemBMK22 DUAL-GARD Oil Bypass System (Large Engines)BMK23 General Use Dual Remote Oil Bypass UnitBMK26 Ford 7.3L PowerStroke Oil Bypass UnitBMK27 GM 6.6L Dual Remote Bypass SystemBMK28 Ford 6.7L Engine Dual Remote By-Pass Filter KitBMK30 Heavy-Duty By-Pass System (Large Engines)BMK31 Ford 6.0/6.4L Single-Remote Bypass SystemBMK32 GM 6.6L Single-Remote Bypass SystemBMK33 Ford 6.7L Single-Remote Bypass SystemBMK34 Cummins 5.0/5.9/6.7L Bypass System
By-Pass Filter Elements Oil AnalysisAmsoil PowerCore™ Air Filters (PCF)Available Substitute Filter BrandsDonaldson Oil & Air Filters
Donaldson Blue Heavy Duty Air FiltersDonaldson Blue Oil FiltersDonaldson P-Series Heavy Duty Air FiltersDonaldson P-Series Oil & Air Filters
MANN-FILTER Oil, Air, Fuel & CabinWIX Oil, Air, Fuel, Cabin Filters & More
ATF & Gear Lube
Transmission FluidsAutomatic Transmission Fluids
20W-50 Hydrostatic Transmission Fluid (AHF)CG-Tractor Hydraulic/Transmission Oil (TCGSB)OE Multi-Vehicle Synthetic ATFOE Series Fuel-Efficient Synthetic ATFSignature Series Fuel-Efficient Synthetic ATFSignature Series Multi-Vehicle Synthetic ATFSignature Series ULV Synthetic ATFTorque-Drive Transmission Fluid (ATD)Tractor Hydraulic/Transmission Oil (ATH)
100% Synthetic CVT Fluid100% Synthetic DCT FluidManual Transmission Fluids
5W 30 Manual Synchromesh Transmission Fluid (MTF)75W-90 (GL-4) Synthetic Gear Lube (MTG)SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic Transmission Oil (FTF)
ATV & UTV Drive Train Fluids
Synthetic ATV/UTV Powertrain FluidATV/UTV Dual-Clutch Transmission FluidATV/UTV Transmission & Differential Fluid
Motorcycle Transmission Fluids
Synthetic Dirt Bike Transmission Fluid (DBTF)V-Twin Synthetic Primary Fluid (MVP)V-Twin Synthetic Transmission Fluid (MVT)
Gear LubeHigh Performance Gear Lube
75W 85 Severe Gear® Extreme Pressure (SVL)75W 90 Severe Gear® Extreme Pressure (SVG)75W-110 Severe Gear® Extreme Pressure (SVT)75W-140 Severe Gear® Extreme Pressure (SVO) 75W-90 (GL-4) Synthetic Gear Lube (MTG)AMSOIL Hand Pump For BottlesAMSOIL Marine Gear Lube PumpSEVERE GEAR 80W-90 (AGL)
Semi Truck Gear Lube
75W-90 Semi-Truck Gear Lube (FGR)80W-140 Semi-Truck Gear Lube (FGO)SAE 50 Long-Life Synthetic Transmission Oil (FTF)
Racing & Off Road Gear Lube
SAE 250 Severe Gear Racing Gear Lubricant (SRT)Super Shift Racing Transmission Fluid (ART)
Marine Gear Lube 75W/80W-90 (AGM)Gear Lube AdditiveLimited Slip Differential (LSD) Additive Powershift Transmission FluidPowershift Transmission Fluids
Powershift Transmission Fluid SAE 10W (CTG)Powershift Transmission Fluid SAE 30 (CTJ)Powershift Transmission Fluid SAE 50 (CTL)
ATF for Racing, Ford Type F & Allison C-4Super Shift Racing Transmission Fluid
Miscellaneous
Grease
100% SYNTHETIC EP NLGI 00 GREASE (GSF)Deluxe Grease Gun KitDOMINATOR Synthetic Racing Grease (GRG)Lithium Complex High Viscosity Grease (GVC)Polymeric Off-Road Grease (GPOR1)Polymeric Off-Road Grease (GPOR2)Polymeric Truck, Chassis & Equipment (GPTR1)Polymeric Truck, Chassis & Equipment (GPTR2)Synthetic Multi-Purpose Grease NLGI #2 (GLC)Synthetic Water Resistant Grease NLGI#2 (GWR)X-Treme Food Grade Grease (GXC)
Engine Flush & Degreaser
Engine and Transmission Flush (FLSH)Engine Degreaser (AED)Exterior Ceramic Spray (CSF)Glass Cleaner (AGC)Heavy Duty Degreaser (ADG) High-Foam Car Shampoo (HFB)Interior Detailer Light Lemon (IDL)Interior Detailer Scent Free (IDN)Miracle Wash (AMW) Mudslinger® (AMS)Power Foam Engine Cleaner & Degreaser (APF)
Spray Lubricants
Chain Lube (ACLSC)Engine Fogging Oil (FOG) MP Heavy Duty Metal Protector (AMH)MP Metal Protector (AMP)Silicone Spray (ALS) Spray Grease (GSP)
Bar & Chain Oil
Semi-Synthetic Bar and Chain Oil (ABC)Synthetic Chain Case & Gear Oil (TCC)
Suspension & Fork Oil
Suspension Fluid #10 Medium (STM)Suspension Fluid #5 Light (STL)
Power Steering FluidDOT Brake Fluid
DOMINATOR DOT 4 Brake Fluid (BFR)DOT 3 and 4 Synthetic Brake Fluid (BFLV)
Antifreeze & Coolant
Antifreeze and Engine Coolant (ANT)Dominator Coolant Boost (RDCB)Heavy-Duty Antifreeze & Coolant (ANTHD)Passenger Vehicle Antifreeze (ANTPC)Powersports Coolant (PSAF)
Air Tool Oil
Synthetic Air Tool Oil (AIR)
Firearm Protectants
Brake and Parts Cleaner (BPC)Firearm Cleaner and Protectant (FCP)Firearm Lubricant and Protectant (FLP)
Industrial Lubricants
Compressor Oils - SyntheticPC Series Compressor Oils Synthetic Compressor OilsSynthetic Compressor OilsDC Series Compressor Oils Sirocco SE Series Ester Compressor OilHydraulic Oils - SyntheticAW Series Antiwear Hydraulic OilsBiodegradable Hydraulic OilSlideway, Chain, Bearing and Gear OilSG SERIES Extreme Pressure Gear OilsHydraulic Oils - SyntheticHV Series Hydraulic OilsWL SERIES Slideway, Chain and Gear LubeRC Series R&O/AW Gear And Bearing OilsHT Series High Temperature Lubricating Oils
Fuel Additive
Gasoline Fuel AdditivesP.I. Performance Improver (API)Upper Cylinder Lubricant (UCL)Dominator Octane Boost (AOB)Gasoline Stabilizer for Storage (AST)Motorcycle Octane BoostMotorcycle Octane Boost (MOB)Small Engines & PowersportsSmall Engines Fuel Treatment & StabilizerDiesel Fuel AdditivesDiesel Injector Clean (ADF)Diesel 4-In-1 (ADB)Diesel Injector Clean + Cetane Boost (ADS)Diesel Cold Flow Improver (ADD)Cetane Boost for Diesel Fuel (ACB)Diesel Recovery Emergency Fuel Treatment
Receive AMSOIL's Confidential Factory Direct Wholesale Price List in your email.
Enter your first name & email address and click on "eMail Price List" button!
AMSOIL Online Store
AMSOIL Preferred Customer Program. Save upto 25%!
Wholesale Business Accounts
Become an AMSOIL Dealer!
Request FREE AMSOIL Catalog
Questions? Please Contact us
Order AMSOIL By Phone
AMSOIL Online Store
Order AMSOIL By Fax
VISA and MASTERCARD is accepted for US and Canada.
Discover and American Express is accepted for US customers only
Go to Top

Select your country.

Canada
Ships from Canada. Prices in CA dollars.
United States
Ships from USA. Prices in US dollars.

Please Wait...

Your request is being processed...